Round 1

What was the name of the author whose book Slave Ship was banned in Australia in 1971? I also need to know why it was banned.

Question posted Monday May 25, 2009

Jane B's answer

Austlit is a database that specialises in Australian literature and is produced by the University of Queensland so I thought that this would be a good place to start this search. I entered “Slave Ship” into the Quick search box and scrolled down the list and found that No. 5 had the entry for Slave Ship with a “banned” symbol next to it.

The author of the book was Eric Corder, the pseudonym for Jerrold Mundis. The biography says he was born in the Midwest USA and is the author of seventeen popular fiction titles, thirteen non fiction books, numerous pseudonymous novels and over 100 short stories, essays and articles. His book Slave Ship was banned in Australia in 1971.

One of the censors wrote that: ‘This is a gruesome, horrifying and apparently semi-factual account of an American slave-ship in the slave trade of the early 19th century. It gives a detailed account of the killing, violence, flogging, torture, rape, brutality, bestiality, sadism and inhuman savagery of the traffic. Most of the book is extremely well written in a tough staccato style, obviously by a professional, and this increases the nauseating effect of the horror.’

The book was released on 29 July 1973.

Access to Austlit is available free from the PCs in Mosman Library.

Ken D's answer

“Slave ship” returns too many results in Google to be of much use. Adding keywords like “novel” and a variety of year dates didn’t help to narrow it down.

I did find an interesting panel discussion Banned books in Australia: from moral crusaders to national security available as a transcript from ABC Radio National but it didn’t shed much light on this particular book.

I changed tack and started searching for lists of banned books in Australia. A cached discussion list email pointed to the government’s Classification Board archives but a search on their database came up blank.

I returned to searching for the author and entered “Slave Ship” in book places like Library Thing and Amazon. Again, too much to sift through, so to get the year, I googled up help on how to find a book that led me to COPAC, combined catalog of the British Library and UK and Irish research libraries

A quick search showed that the only book from the early 1970s with that title was by Eric Corder.

Then I ran out of time.

Comments have now closed

Your say

This is fantastic. I’ll be following with great interest. So far Mosman Library has much more interesting relevant results!

Diana   posted 25 May 2009    #

This will be a very interesting exercise.
Nada

Nada    posted 25 May 2009    #

This is fun – and a neat way to find out about available library resources.

Matt Amacker   posted 25 May 2009    #

Mosman Library nailed that round!!

Wang Library   posted 25 May 2009    #

This is fantastic – great work Mosman Library !!

— George   posted 25 May 2009    #

A great resource for K-12 students! Thank you!!!!

Lee   posted 25 May 2009    #

Noticed that Jane B got her answer from a database on the net. Can’t have your cake and eat it.

— Rodster   posted 25 May 2009    #

Go the “real” resources, libraries rock!!!!

— Adele   posted 25 May 2009    #

This is so much fun, on a serious topic. Keep it up!

— Ruth   posted 25 May 2009    #

Mosman Library won by a long shot….good job!

— Other Jane   posted 25 May 2009    #

OMG poor Ken. I’d be getting so stressed out and frustrated. I get annoyed that once upon a time the internet was supposed to be for gathering information (wasn’t it???) and now it seems to be all about trying to sell something. You have to search and search just to get a plain old bit of information. Jane wins – too easy!

— Jeannie   posted 25 May 2009    #

Someone could write a thesis on how ‘that search engine’ earned 122 votes – very weird!

— Ann   posted 25 May 2009    #

Mosman Library well done! Both for content and interest. Knowledge of databases a bonus.

— Steph   posted 26 May 2009    #

So glad to hear the Library won.

I went looking for a list of banned books – did a search and really didn’t find an Australian list until I mentioned it to one of the staff here who indexes for AustLit and she pointed me to the AustLit’s ‘Banned in Australia’ subset.

ps: Although AustLit is produced by the University of Queensland, the staff who index for AustLit are located around Australia. The Academy Library – UNSW@ADFA have 2 of their best.
Sometimes it is not what you know but who you know.

Lyn   posted 26 May 2009    #

If there book was published in 1973 how could it have been banned in 1971?

— Kim   posted 26 May 2009    #

Hi Kim, according to AustLit, ‘Slave Ship’ was first published in 1969 in the USA and then in 1970 in the UK. It was banned in Australia in 1971 and ‘released’ from its prohibited status in 1973.

Tessa (your friendly AustLit indexer)   posted 26 May 2009    #

Jane B’s information was great and very detailed – she gets my vote this time.

— Barbara   posted 26 May 2009    #

What a great idea! Will keep watching over the week.

— Claire   posted 26 May 2009    #

I wonder if a librarian searching “that search engine” might do better than an IT guy… not sure it’s a fair fight ;-)

— Naomi    posted 26 May 2009    #

Reply to Rodster:

Jane B got her information from a database that, while on the internet, is not FREELY AVAILABLE on the internet. The point of this contest is to test library resources (in this case databases on the internet) against information found freely online, through Google.

— Naomi    posted 26 May 2009    #

How could That Search Engine get any votes on this one. Ken D did all that could be asked but TSE came up well short.

— Brian Field   posted 26 May 2009    #

I don’t understand the comment, “Noticed that Jane B got her answer from a database on the net. Can’t have your cake and eat it.” The point is that she’s using library databases (generally subscription although not always), available on the internet. He is using websites available on the world wide web, which is also part of the internet. They are two very different kinds of resources.

— Cynthia   posted 26 May 2009    #

Looks like Ken is not representative of someone doing internet based research for a book. Try doing a book search on “that search engine” for the exact title and published in 1971. Comes up as first hit. So that took about 1 minute for the first part of the question, by a non-librarian.

— Chris   posted 27 May 2009    #

I really don’t know how TSE got any votes, he didn’t even answer the question wheras Jane B answered the question brilliantly. Rodster, whilst databases are on the internet they are more authoritative and tend to be journal or newspaper articles chosen to be on the databases not information written and published by anyone like you can get using a search engine.

— Kylie   posted 27 May 2009    #

Kylie, take a deep breath and a lie down! Its only a promotion! Try not to lose too much sleep over it. Both are doing a great job. :-)

— MarionGirl   posted 28 May 2009    #

Round  1 2 3 4 5

The Set Up

We’re pitting Mosman Library’s online reference collection against what you can find from the search box on the world wide web!

Each day during Library & Information Week we’ll be posting a question that represents the range of queries that we get at Mosman Library.

The questions have been moderated by Ellen Forsyth of the State Library of NSW.

You decide who gives the best answers and wins the challenge.

The Players

Our Reference Librarian Jane B will represent Mosman Library. She’ll use only Mosman Library’s electronic resources to answer the question.

Our Internet & IT Services Librarian Ken D will represent the search engine. He’ll use only freely-available web resources to formulate his answer.

The Rules

Each player has 45 minutes to research the question.

They have another 45 minutes to write up their answer and outline their search strategy.

Each day’s question will go online at 10am AEST. The answers will be published at noon.

You can vote once on each round. Voting will be open for 24 hours for each round.

The winner will be presented the trophy on Monday 1 June.

The Cup

Want to know what we’re playing for?

The 2009 Challenge Cup is a superb GIF hand-crafted by Mosman Council’s graphic designer.

It will be awarded to the team that has won the most rounds at the close of voting on Saturday 30 May.